HPC in the media: the myth of shareholder stewardship
Our analysis of shareholder voting patterns makes the case against a corporate governance system policed by dis-engaged investors
Our report 'The Myth of Shareholder Stewardship' published this week was covered extensively in the media.
The report analysed voting patterns at shareholder AGMs over the past 5 years, finding very little evidence of investor stewardship. For example, the average pay-related resolution was waved through with 91% approval.
Across more than 700 pay-related resolutions voted on at AGMs over the period, the average level of shareholder dissent was just 8.8%. Only 11% of pay-related resolutions attracted ‘significant’ dissent levels of over 20%. Every single FTSE 100 company pay policy put to AGMs was approved by shareholders.
Given the strength of feeling over executive pay, this suggests that the shareholder-policed corporate governance system is not delivering good outcomes for society. Recent opinion polls have repeatedly shown that more people agree that the interests of big business run contrary to those of society than disagree. There is also consistent support for capping CEO pay and for prioritising reducing inequality over economic growth.
Selected highlights from the media coverage included a discussion with HPC Director Luke Hildyard on BBC Radio 4's Today programme, plus news articles in the Guardian, Daily Mail, Daily Mirror and on the BBC News website.
There was also an excellent comment piece by James Moore in the Independent.
Since 1 January 2020 the average FTSE 100 CEO has earned:
Income inequality in the UK
Wealth inequality in the UK
- High Pay Centre Briefing: Corporate Response to the Economic Shutdown
At least 18% of FTSE 100 firms are using the UK Government's furlough scheme. 37% have cut executive pay and 33% are withdrawing or withholding dividend payments
- Blog: we can’t do more for low-paid workers without tackling excess pay at the top
recognition of low-paid workers is welcome, but for things to change, we need tough choices not warm words. Changes to corporate governance structures, stronger trade union rights and more progressive taxation
- Conditions are critical: publicly-funded bail-outs for private companies
Government bail-outs of large businesses affected by the coronavirus must include social and environmental conditions including fair pay, fair tax contributions and worker representation on company boards